The short answer
The most common mistakes are a slow or outdated website, an incomplete Google Business Profile, no review strategy, posting on social without a plan, running ads without tracking, ignoring email and not measuring results. Fixing those basics usually brings more leads than adding any new channel.
After working with businesses across Memphis, Germantown, Collierville, Bartlett, Cordova, Southaven, and Olive Branch, we’ve seen the same digital marketing mistakes come up over and over. These aren’t obscure or complicated problems. They’re the same gaps that keep showing up — and they’re costing Memphis businesses real leads, real customers, and real revenue.
Here are the seven most common ones, and what to do about each.
Mistake number one is almost always the same: nearly 90% of consumers say they’ll shop with a competitor after just one poor website experience, according to LocaliQ’s small business marketing statistics report. Every mistake below compounds that risk.
Mistake 1: Treating Social Media as an Afterthought
The most common version of this: a Facebook page that hasn’t been posted on in three months. An Instagram account with 12 posts, the most recent from a year ago. A TikTok account that was created in a moment of enthusiasm and then abandoned.
Inconsistent social media isn’t just neutral — it actively hurts your credibility. When a potential Memphis customer looks you up on social media and sees a dormant account, it raises a red flag. Is this business still open? Are they still doing good work? Why hasn’t anyone posted recently?
The fix: post consistently, or don’t post at all. A clean, professional account with no recent posts is better than one that shows months-long gaps. Better still, build a realistic content calendar you can actually maintain — even two or three posts per week is meaningful if it’s consistent.
Mistake 2: Having a Website That Was Great in 2018
Your website is working for you (or against you) 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Memphis consumers who look you up online form an instant judgment about your professionalism, quality, and trustworthiness based on your site — often before they’ve read a single word.
An outdated design, slow load times, a site that doesn’t work on mobile, broken links, or stock photos that look nothing like your actual business all communicate the same thing: this company isn’t paying attention.
The fix: audit your website honestly. Pull it up on your phone and walk through it as a potential customer would. If it doesn’t load quickly, look professional, and make it easy to contact you or buy from you, it needs work.
Mistake 3: Ignoring Google Reviews
Memphis consumers read reviews. According to BrightLocal, 93% of consumers check online reviews before visiting a business, and 91% trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations. Your Google review count and rating directly affect both your local search ranking and your conversion rate from search to customer.
The most common mistake: not asking for reviews. Most happy customers will leave a review if asked directly — especially if you make it easy by sending them a direct link. The fix: build a systematic review request process. Ask every satisfied customer. Make it a habit, not an afterthought.
Mistake 4: Running Paid Ads Without a Strategy
“We tried Google Ads and it didn’t work” is something we hear regularly from Memphis businesses. In almost every case, the ads weren’t the problem — the strategy was. Targeting too broad an audience. Sending ad traffic to a homepage instead of a landing page designed to convert. Running campaigns without conversion tracking so there’s no way to know what’s working. Stopping campaigns too early before the algorithm has enough data to optimize.
The fix: before spending money on ads, get clear on your goal (what specific action do you want people to take?), your audience (who specifically in the Memphis area are you targeting?), your landing page (where are you sending them and is that page designed to convert?), and your tracking (how will you know if it’s working?).
Mistake 5: Not Claiming and Optimizing Their Google Business Profile
This one still surprises us. In 2025, there are still Memphis businesses with unclaimed Google Business Profiles — meaning they have no control over the information that appears when people search for them. And among those who have claimed their profile, many haven’t updated it since the initial setup.
The fix: claim your profile at business.google.com if you haven’t already. Then audit it completely: correct your hours, add recent photos, update your services list, write a keyword-rich description, and start posting updates at least twice a month.
Mistake 6: Producing Content Without a Distribution Plan
This is the “if you build it they will come” fallacy applied to content marketing. A Memphis business writes a blog post, publishes it to their website, and waits for traffic. When no traffic comes, they conclude that content marketing doesn’t work.
Content without distribution is a tree falling in an empty forest. The fix: every piece of content you create should have a specific distribution plan. Where will you share it? Which social media platforms? Does it go in your email newsletter? Can it be repurposed into a short-form video? Can you submit it to local Memphis media or business publications? Great content that nobody sees accomplishes nothing.
Mistake 7: Not Knowing Their Numbers
The final mistake — and the one that underlies all the others — is not measuring what’s working. Memphis businesses that don’t track their marketing performance can’t make intelligent decisions about where to invest more and where to stop spending.
At minimum, every Memphis business should know: how many people visit their website each month, where that traffic comes from, how many of those visitors contact them, and what actions they take. Google Analytics (free) and Google Search Console (free) provide this data. If you’re not looking at it regularly, you’re flying blind.
The fix: set up tracking if you haven’t already. Check your numbers monthly. If a marketing channel isn’t generating traffic, leads, or sales — even after giving it a fair runway — redirect that budget to something that is.
The Common Thread
Every mistake on this list has the same root cause: doing marketing reactively instead of strategically. The businesses that grow consistently in Memphis are the ones that approach marketing with intention — a clear strategy, consistent execution, and regular measurement.
If you’d like an honest assessment of where your Memphis business’s marketing stands right now, Big River Digital offers free marketing audits. We’ll look at your website, your Google presence, your social media, and your listings and tell you exactly what we’d prioritize — no pressure, no fluff.
Book a Free Marketing Audit. Learn more: Free SEO audit, SEO services, and About us.


