The short answer
Run Google Ads first if people already search for what you sell, because you reach them at the moment they need you. Start with Facebook and Instagram ads if you need to create demand or your offer is visual. Many Memphis businesses end up using both, with Google for intent and Meta for awareness.
“Should I run Google Ads or Facebook Ads?” is one of the most common questions Memphis business owners ask when they’re ready to invest in paid advertising. It’s also one of the most frequently given bad answers — because the honest truth is that the right choice depends entirely on your specific business, your goals, and where your customers are in their buying journey.
This guide gives you a clear, no-nonsense framework for making that decision — using real data and practical examples relevant to Memphis businesses.
The Fundamental Difference: Intent vs. Discovery
Understanding why Google Ads and Facebook Ads work the way they do starts with understanding one core difference: Google captures existing demand, while Facebook creates new demand.
When someone searches “emergency plumber Memphis” on Google, they have a problem right now and they’re actively looking for a solution. Google Ads puts your business in front of that person at the exact moment of need. The intent to buy is already there — you’re simply competing to be the business they call.
When someone sees your ad in their Facebook or Instagram feed, they weren’t looking for you. They were scrolling through content, and your ad interrupted them. The best Facebook and Instagram ads make people aware of something they didn’t know they needed, or remind them of something they’ve been thinking about. It’s awareness and consideration, not immediate conversion.
Neither approach is better in absolute terms. They solve different problems at different stages of the customer journey. Knowing which problem you need to solve right now determines which platform to start with.
When Google Ads Is the Right Choice for Memphis Businesses
Google Ads is almost always the better starting point for Memphis businesses that offer services people actively search for when they need them. If customers find you by typing a specific need into a search bar, Google Ads is your highest-intent, fastest-return channel.
Best fits for Google Ads in Memphis:
- Home services — plumbing, HVAC, roofing, landscaping, pest control, electrical
- Legal services — personal injury, family law, criminal defense, estate planning
- Medical and dental — urgent care, dentists, specialists, physical therapy
- Auto repair and detailing
- Contractors and construction
- Financial services where clients search for specific expertise
The numbers support this: Google Ads average click-through rate across all industries is 6.66% — dramatically higher than Facebook’s 1-2% — because users are actively seeking the result. For service-based Memphis businesses, Google Ads typically delivers faster ROI and higher-quality leads because the person clicking already has purchase intent.
The tradeoff: Google Ads are more expensive per click. In competitive Memphis industries like legal and healthcare, cost-per-click can be significant. But when a single converted lead is worth hundreds or thousands of dollars, the economics still work strongly in your favor.
When Facebook and Instagram Ads Are the Right Choice
Facebook and Instagram Ads (both managed through Meta’s Ads Manager) are the better choice for Memphis businesses that benefit from visual storytelling, discovery-based purchasing, or reaching a highly specific demographic audience with awareness campaigns.
Best fits for Facebook/Instagram Ads in Memphis:
- Restaurants and food businesses — show food photography and video to local audiences
- Retail and boutique shops — showcase products to shoppers who aren’t yet searching
- Fitness studios, gyms, and wellness businesses — build community awareness
- Event venues and entertainment — promote specific upcoming events
- Real estate — showcase properties and neighborhoods to targeted demographics
- E-commerce brands — visual product ads with retargeting
- Any business running a promotion, grand opening, or seasonal campaign
The cost advantage with Facebook is real: average cost-per-click is significantly lower than Google. For awareness campaigns where your goal is reach and brand recognition rather than immediate conversion, this makes Facebook and Instagram highly efficient.
The Cost Reality for Memphis Businesses
Costs vary by industry, competition, and targeting, but here’s a useful baseline: Google Ads average cost-per-click across all industries is approximately $4.22, while Facebook Ads average around $0.49. Google leads tend to be higher quality — more purchase-ready — but they cost more to acquire. Facebook leads cost less but often require more nurturing before conversion.
For most Memphis service businesses, a realistic starting budget for Google Ads is $800 to $1,500 per month to generate meaningful data and leads. Facebook and Instagram campaigns can begin generating results at $500 to $1,000 per month for most local businesses.
The Answer Most Memphis Businesses Don’t Want to Hear: Both
The highest-performing Memphis businesses use Google Ads and Facebook/Instagram Ads together — not as competitors, but as complementary tools that serve different parts of the customer journey. Google captures people who are ready to buy right now. Facebook keeps your brand in front of people who have visited your website but haven’t converted yet (retargeting), builds awareness among new audiences, and drives repeat business from existing customers.
If budget requires choosing one to start: service businesses should start with Google. Product and experience-based businesses should often start with Facebook and Instagram. Then layer in the second platform as budget allows.
Big River Digital manages paid advertising campaigns for Memphis businesses across both Google and Meta — with clear tracking, honest reporting, and no “set it and forget it” management. Book a free consultation below to talk through what paid advertising would look like for your specific business and budget.
CTA
Book a Free Paid Advertising Consultation → https://bigriverdigital.ai/

